Linguistic Operation-Based English Names for Arabic Rhetorical Devices

    From The Encyclopedia of Arabic Rhetoric
    About this page
    Created7 October 2026
    Modified2 November 2026
     
    Cite this page
    🔗 DOI10.64393/balagha.LO.names
     
    Use this page
    DownloadPDF     JSON     HTML

    Background

    The Encyclopedia of Arabic Rhetoric uses English names for Arabic rhetorical devices in order to make the taxonomy accessible to English-speaking readers and operationally usable for annotation, computational analysis, and related applications. These names are governed by the English Naming Policy for Arabic Rhetorical Devices, which aims to balance intelligibility, fidelity to the Arabic rhetorical tradition, and accurate identification of each device's Linguistic Operation.

    Historical development

    During the development of the taxonomy, some Arabic rhetorical devices were assigned English names that were identical or similar to the names of ordinary grammatical, linguistic, communicative, or discourse phenomena. Examples included The Interrogative, Verbosity, Digression, Conjunction, and Definiteness.

    Although these names were intelligible translations or descriptions, they created a potential ambiguity for annotation: the English name could suggest that the underlying grammatical or discourse phenomenon was itself sufficient for annotation, rather than distinguishing the phenomenon from its rhetorically operative use.

    Development of the Model for Rhetorical Action

    In 2026, the Encyclopedia developed and adopted the Model for Rhetorical Action as the epistemological and theoretical foundation for the Encyclopedia's approach to the identification and analysis of Arabic rhetorical devices. The Model states that a linguistic rhetorical action is a four-step process through which:

    1. A communicator typically acts with a communicative intention and
    2. Employs a rhetorical device as the instrument of an identifiable linguistic action,
    3. Which is capable of establishing or activating a cognitive relationship between the communicator and the addressee,
    4. Which may produce an enhancement of the communicative effect of the communicator's message in the addressee.


    Step 2 of the Model is known as the Linguistic Operation step. It highlights the difference between a linguistic action - such as a repetition, a repositioning of words, an intentional concordance of sounds - and a Linguistic Operation, which is a linguistic action undertaken in the context of linguistic rhetorical action.

    For example, a linguistic action such as the use of an interrogative construction does not by itself create an instance of the Linguistic Operation traditionally discussed under the Arabic term al-istifhām (The Interrogative). Similarly, ordinary verbosity, an everyday change of topic, a grammatical conjunction, or the normal use of definite particles does not instantiate the corresponding rhetorical device.

    It became apparent that some historical rhetorical device names in English allude to the linguistic action rather than the Linguistic Operation. This is particularly important for annotation. A rhetorical device name such as "The Interrogative" can appear to identify a grammatical category and may encourage annotation on the basis of grammatical form alone, rather than rhetorical function. This can be confusing for users of the Encyclopedia.

    Re-naming for alignment with the Model for Rhetorical Action

    An audit in October 2026 of the English names of all 79 current Level 1 rhetorical device annotation units resulted in:

    • 62 names being retained unchanged.
    • 17 names being revised as per the mapping table below, to align them with each device's Linguistic Operation:


    Previous identifier Previous English name Revised identifier Revised English name
    AFFIRM Affirmation unchanged Rhetorical Affirmation
    CHNGTOP Change of Topic unchanged Rhetorical Change of Topic
    CONJUN Conjunction unchanged Rhetorical Conjunction
    DEFINT Definiteness unchanged Rhetorical Definiteness
    DIGRESS Digression unchanged Rhetorical Digression
    DISJUN Disjunction unchanged Rhetorical Disjunction
    IMPERAT The Imperative unchanged The Rhetorical Imperative
    INDEF Indefiniteness unchanged Rhetorical Indefiniteness
    INTEROG The Interrogative unchanged The Rhetorical Interrogative
    PROHIB Prohibition unchanged Rhetorical Prohibition
    RESTRCT Restriction unchanged Rhetorical Restriction
    RETRACT Retraction unchanged Rhetorical Retraction
    RHYMED Rhymed Prose unchanged Rhetorical Rhymed Prose
    SYNGRP Syntactic Grouping GROUP Rhetorical Grouping
    VERBOS Verbosity unchanged Rhetorical Verbosity
    VOCATIV The Vocative unchanged The Rhetorical Vocative
    WISH Wishing unchanged Rhetorical Wishing

    Page History

    • 2026-10-07 - Page created following a review of the English names of all 79 Level 1 annotation units.